10 Tips to Improve Email Sender Reputation 2024 - RealMail
Want to boost your email marketing success? Here's how to improve your sender reputation:
Keep your email list updated
Check and reduce bounce rates
Create engaging email content
Send emails on a regular schedule
Get subscribers to interact with emails
Handle unsubscribes quickly
Use email feedback loops
Monitor your sender reputation
Gradually increase email volume on new IPs
Quick Comparison:
Tip | Key Benefit | Difficulty |
---|---|---|
Email authentication | Prevents spoofing | Medium |
List maintenance | Reduces bounces | Easy |
Bounce rate reduction | Improves deliverability | Medium |
Engaging content | Increases open rates | Hard |
Consistent scheduling | Builds trust | Easy |
Subscriber interaction | Boosts engagement | Medium |
Quick unsubscribes | Prevents complaints | Easy |
Feedback loops | Identifies issues | Medium |
Reputation monitoring | Catches problems early | Easy |
IP warming | Builds credibility | Medium |
Follow these tips to land in inboxes, not spam folders. Remember: Your sender reputation needs constant attention to maintain strong email marketing performance.
Related video from YouTube
Use Email Authentication
Email authentication is your digital ID for messages. It tells inbox providers, "This email is really from us!"
Why it matters:
Stops email fakery
Boosts inbox chances
Shows you're serious about security
Three key players:
1. SPF (Sender Policy Framework)
SPF is your bouncer. It lists which servers can send emails for your domain.
Setup:
Add TXT record to DNS
Include: "v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com ~all"
2. DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail)
DKIM adds a digital signature to your emails.
Setup:
Generate key in email provider's admin console
Add public key to DNS records
3. DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance)
DMARC tells receiving servers what to do with emails that fail SPF or DKIM checks.
Setup:
Create TXT record in DNS
Use: "v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; rua=mailto:reports@yourdomain.com"
Quick comparison:
Protocol | Function | Importance |
---|---|---|
SPF | Lists allowed senders | Stops spoofing |
DKIM | Adds digital signature | Verifies integrity |
DMARC | Sets rules for failed emails | Gives clear instructions |
Heads up: Gmail and Yahoo now require these for bulk senders (5000+ emails daily).
Marcel Becker from Yahoo says:
"All of these requirements have been well documented best practices for years. A lot of senders have already implemented them. Authenticating your email traffic should be something that you're already doing if you care about the health of your email traffic as well as your infrastructure."
Set these up now. Your sender reputation will thank you.
2. Keep Your Email List Updated
Think of your email list as a garden. Let it grow wild, and you'll end up with a mess. Here's how to keep it tidy:
Prune regularly
Clean your list every 3-6 months. Remove bounced emails, inactive subscribers, and unsubscribes. Why? A clean list boosts your sender score and keeps costs down.
Double opt-in: Your secret weapon
Use double opt-in to verify email addresses, reduce spam complaints, and improve engagement rates. It's like a VIP check at the door of your email club.
Re-engage or remove
Got quiet subscribers? Try this:
Send a "We miss you" campaign
Offer something valuable
If no response, say goodbye
A smaller, engaged list ALWAYS beats a big, unresponsive one.
Watch for red flags
Keep an eye on these metrics:
Metric | Warning Sign | Action |
---|---|---|
Bounce rate | Over 2% | Remove invalid addresses |
Open rate | Below 15% | Segment and re-engage |
Spam complaints | Any | Remove immediately |
Use tools to stay sharp
Email validation tools can catch typos at signup, verify old lists, and flag risky addresses. They're like spell-check for your email list.
The 25% rule
Your list naturally shrinks about 25% each year. People change jobs, switch emails, or lose interest. Stay ahead by continuously growing your list, updating contact info, and removing inactive subscribers.
Remember: A well-maintained email list is the foundation of successful email marketing. Keep it clean, and your campaigns will thrive.
3. Check and Reduce Bounce Rates
Bounces can wreck your email marketing efforts. Keeping your bounce rate under 2% is key for a good sender reputation.
There are two types of bounces:
Hard bounces: Permanent failures (non-existent email addresses)
Soft bounces: Temporary issues (full inboxes, server problems)
Both can hurt your sender score if ignored. ISPs use bounce rates to judge email senders.
Here's how to fight bounces:
Clean your list every 3-6 months
Use double opt-in
Segment subscribers by engagement
Send consistently
Watch your bounce rates closely
Use this quick guide:
Bounce Rate | What to Do |
---|---|
< 2% | You're good |
2% - 5% | Clean your list |
> 5% | Major cleanup needed |
Pro tip: Use email validation tools to catch mistakes before they hit your list.
"Watch for emails that always bounce", says Natalie Sullivan, ex-retention marketing manager at Avex Designs. "High bounce rates can hurt your reputation, so keep your list updated."
4. Create Engaging Email Content
Want your emails to actually get read? Here's how to make them irresistible:
Nail Your Subject Lines
Your subject line can make or break your email. Keep it short and punchy:
Create urgency: "50% off ends tonight!"
Ask questions: "Want higher open rates?"
Use numbers: "5 ways to boost your sender score"
Personalize It
Generic emails are out. Use subscriber data to tailor your content:
Include the recipient's name
Mention past purchases
Suggest products based on browsing history
Keep It Snappy
No one wants a novel in their inbox. Get to the point:
Short paragraphs (2-3 sentences max)
Use bullet points
Clear call-to-action (CTA)
Mobile-Friendly Is Key
84% of 18-34 year olds use email preview panes. Make sure your emails look good on small screens:
Single-column layout
Big, thumb-friendly CTAs (at least 44x44 pixels)
Test on multiple devices
A/B Test Everything
Don't guess - test. Try different:
Subject lines
Send times
CTA buttons
Images vs. no images
Test Element | Option A | Option B |
---|---|---|
Subject Line | "Sale ends soon!" | "Don't miss out on 50% off" |
Send Time | Tuesday 10 AM | Thursday 3 PM |
CTA Button | "Shop Now" (green) | "Get Deal" (red) |
What works for one audience might flop for another. Keep testing and tweaking.
"Know what you want the outcome to be, and make sure they know it too." - Sam Bennett, Email Guru
5. Send Emails on a Regular Schedule
Want to boost your sender reputation? Stick to a consistent email schedule. Here's why it matters and how to do it:
Why Consistency Counts
Sending emails on a set schedule isn't just about being organized. It's crucial for:
Building trust with subscribers
Improving open rates
Reducing spam complaints
If your subscribers know when to expect your emails, they're more likely to open them. Plus, a steady stream of emails helps you spot inactive subscribers.
Finding Your Perfect Rhythm
There's no one-size-fits-all answer for email frequency. But here's a quick guide:
Frequency | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|
2-3 times/week | Highest engagement | Risk of fatigue |
Once/week | Good balance | May miss opportunities |
4-5 times/week | More touchpoints | Lower engagement |
Pro tip: Let your subscribers choose. Set up a preference center where they can pick their preferred frequency.
Best Days and Times to Send
Recent data suggests:
Best days: Tuesday, Thursday, Friday
Best times: 9-11 AM, 1-2 PM
But don't just take our word for it. Test different send times with your audience.
Sticking to Your Schedule
Use an email marketing tool with scheduling features
Plan your content calendar in advance
Set up automated workflows for consistent sends
Quality trumps quantity. Don't sacrifice content value just to hit a frequency target.
Breaking Your Schedule
If you need to deviate from your usual schedule:
Give subscribers a heads-up
Explain why
Let them know when you'll be back on track
The Bottom Line
A consistent email schedule is like a heartbeat for your email marketing. It keeps your sender reputation strong and your subscribers engaged. Start modest, test different options, and always prioritize valuable content over volume.
Stop Losing Customers to Invalid Emails
Optimize your onboarding process and protect your sender reputation with RealMail's powerful email validation service. Prevent mistakes before they happen and drive more conversions for your business.
6. Get Subscribers to Interact with Emails
Want better sender reputation? Make your emails irresistible. Here's how:
Personalize Like a Pro
Ditch the generic blasts. Get personal:
Use names in subject lines
Tailor content to past interactions
Segment your list
EPS Group saw engagement spike after personalizing subject lines. Their communications manager said:
"It's the personalization that really does it for us."
Make It Visual
People love eye candy:
Add relevant images
Include short videos
Use clean, mobile-friendly design
46% of email opens happen on mobile. Don't forget that.
Ask for Action
Don't just inform—inspire:
Use clear, compelling CTAs
Try polls or quizzes
Add social sharing buttons
Timing Is Everything
Send when your audience is ready:
Best Days | Best Times |
---|---|
Tuesday | 9-11 AM |
Thursday | 1-2 PM |
Friday | 3-4 PM |
Test these times with your audience.
Offer Value
Give reasons to open and click:
Share exclusive content
Provide helpful tips
Run contests
Track and Improve
Use data to get better:
Monitor open rates, clicks, and conversions
A/B test everything
Remove inactive subscribers
Exemplis, a manufacturing company, hit 70% open rates on weekly emails after tracking engagement.
7. Handle Unsubscribes Quickly
Breakups happen. When subscribers want out, make it quick and painless.
Why It Matters
Slow unsubscribes hurt your sender rep. Here's the scoop:
Average unsubscribe rate: 0.17%
Good unsubscribe rate: Under 0.5%
Higher? Time to rethink your email strategy.
Speed Is Everything
Remove unsubscribers FAST. Here's why:
Slow Unsubscribes | Quick Unsubscribes |
---|---|
Spam complaints | Happy ex-subscribers |
Damaged reputation | Better deliverability |
Legal troubles | Compliance with laws |
Make It Simple
Clear unsubscribe link
One-click process (no login)
Confirmation page (not email)
Offer Choices
Let subscribers customize:
Email frequency
Content types
Temporary pause
J. Crew does this well. They let users pick frequency and email categories.
Learn and Improve
Use unsubscribe data:
Track rates
Analyze reasons
Adjust strategy
Make It Memorable
Follow the Rules
CAN-SPAM Act requires:
Working unsubscribe link for 30 days
Honor requests within 10 days
"If you don't allow for an obvious way to unsubscribe, you'll be violating CAN-SPAM." - TermsFeed
8. Use Email Feedback Loops
Email Feedback Loops (FBLs) are your direct line to subscribers' thoughts on your emails. When someone hits "Mark as Spam", FBLs let you know. This helps you remove complainers, spot issues, and boost deliverability.
Setting Up FBLs
To get started:
Own your domain/IP
Set up a postmaster@ or abuse@ email
Configure DNS records
Maintain a good sender rep
Most big ISPs offer FBLs, including Gmail, Yahoo!, and Outlook.
FBLs in Action
1. You send an email
Your newsletter goes out to your list.
2. A subscriber marks it as spam
This is where FBLs shine.
3. The ISP sends you a report
You get a notification about the complaint.
4. You take action
Remove the complainer from your list ASAP.
Real-World FBL Examples
ISP | FBL Process | Key Requirement |
---|---|---|
Gmail Postmaster Tools | Daily reports on spam rates | SPF, DKIM, DMARC authentication |
Outlook JMRP | Daily junk email reports | SPF, DKIM, ideally DMARC |
Yahoo Feedback Loops | Real-time spam complaints | DKIM authentication |
FBL Best Practices
Remove complainers immediately
Look for trends in complaints
Use insights to improve content and targeting
Check FBL reports often
ISPs are watching. Microsoft aims for complaint rates below 0.3%. Keep yours low to stay in their good books.
The FBL Payoff
Using FBLs right can lead to lower complaint rates, better deliverability, and a stronger sender reputation. You keep your list clean, and ISPs see you're on top of things.
9. Keep an Eye on Your Sender Reputation
Your sender reputation is crucial for landing in inboxes, not spam folders. Here's how to stay on top of it:
Mix Up Your Tools
Don't just use one tool. Try these:
Sender Score: Free tool that rates your IP from 1-100. Aim for 80+.
Google Postmaster Tools: Great for Gmail-heavy senders. Shows domain rep from bad to high.
Talos Intelligence: Quick "Good", "Neutral", or "Poor" rating for your domain and IP.
Microsoft SNDS: See how Outlook.com views your sending practices.
Key Metrics to Watch
Metric | Good | Not So Good |
---|---|---|
Sender Score | 80-100 | Under 70 |
Spam Complaints | < 0.1% | > 0.3% |
Bounce Rate | < 2% | > 5% |
Blocklist Status | Not listed | On any major blocklist |
Fix It If It's Broken
Bad scores? Try these:
Clean your list
Sort out authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)
Tweak your sending volume and frequency
Boost your content and targeting
Katherine Pachowicz from CampSaver saw real results:
"We were struggling with inbox placement... We worked to improve our sender reputation. By launch time, we felt confident enough to send to our full list."
Stay on Top of It
Set a monthly reminder to check. Catch issues early, keep those emails flowing to inboxes.
10. Gradually Increase Email Volume on New IPs
Got a new IP for email sending? Don't go full throttle right away. Here's how to warm it up:
1. Start small
Send 20-50 emails per day at first. This keeps you off ISPs' radar.
2. Ramp up gradually
Double your volume every few days. Here's a sample:
Day | Daily Email Limit |
---|---|
1-3 | 50 |
4-6 | 100 |
7-9 | 200 |
10-12 | 400 |
13-15 | 800 |
3. Target engaged users
Focus on active subscribers who interact with your emails.
4. Monitor closely
Watch these metrics:
Bounce rates (under 2%)
Spam complaints (below 0.1%)
Open rates
Click-through rates
See red flags? Slow down.
5. Be patient
Full IP warm-up takes 4-8 weeks. Don't rush.
Think of ISPs like banks. New IPs are like people with no credit history. You need to build trust over time.
Conclusion
Email sender reputation can make or break your email marketing. It's not just about blasting out emails. You need to send the right messages to the right people at the right time.
Here's how to boost your sender reputation:
Action | Impact |
---|---|
Authenticate emails | ISPs trust you more |
Clean email lists | Fewer bounces and complaints |
Monitor metrics | Catch problems early |
Engage subscribers | Better open and click rates |
Warm up new IPs | Build credibility slowly |
Your sender reputation isn't set in stone. It needs constant attention.
Charlie Wijen from Philips nails it:
"We are clear there's a straight-line relationship between better inbox placement performance and Philips' program revenue. We also now have a deep understanding of what affects our deliverability and why, which has improved our engagement levels significantly."
This shows how sender reputation directly impacts your bottom line.
Keep an eye on new rules, too. Gmail and Yahoo! are tightening up authentication in February 2024. Bulk senders will need custom domains, making sender reputation even more crucial.